Critical Eye: K-pop takes top five spots on Japanese download rankings … for K-pop

So apparently dwango, a Japanese music download company, has a K-pop category for its ringtone download rankings, and to anybody with a brain, it would seem logical that Korean artists would dominate that chart. Well, apparently allkpop missed the memo, because they wrote it up like it was a fucking accomplishment.

Big Bang, KARA, Jang Geun Suk, & Super Junior rank top 5 on Japan’s dwango half-year ranking chart

dwango Mobile, a music download service primarily for Android smartphones, has just revealed its ringtone download ranking for the first half of 2012!

The original article on tokyohive was from the Japanese media, and it just reported the results of multiple dwango charts, so I guess somebody at allkpop decided that K-pop artists taking the top five spots on a … K-pop chart is somehow notable.

< K-POP Life Ranking >
01. FANTASTIC BABY – BIGBANG
02. Crazy Crazy Crazy – Jang Geun Suk
03. Speed Up – KARA
04. Oppa, Opaa – SUPER JUNIOR DONGHAE & EUNHYUK
05. Opera – SUPER JUNIOR

It’s like making an Olympic Games only for Koreans, holding it in Japan, and then running a media story hyping up the fact that only Koreans won medals or something.

The fuck?

23 comments

  1. Anything to boost the “Hallyu Wave,” right? AKP would fit right in with the majority of Korean journalists.

  2. Thought so. I questioned how relevant each site was. I think the question is though

    “Why is it kpop acts that dominate and not jpop?”
    So they assume kpop is better etc.

  3. Dumb bitches are dumb. Maybe if they read the chart titles clearer and have common sense…

    I just want to be a guest reporter or something at SBC or MNet for a day: “So how does it feel that the majority of Kpop fans across the globe are delusional illiterate windbags? You realize that the wave ‘dominating the west’ is a propaganda stunt and its merely is and always be a niche market?”
    They’ll never take me alive ’cause I’ll tell it all!

  4. Kpop fans will scrape the barrel for anything to make it look like idols are an international success.

  5. =.=” AKP is really stupid. I don’t get kpop fans, it’s like 99% of the world doesn’t know or give a shit about kpop. Your little “wave” is more like a splash in a toilet bowl.

  6. Don’t know if the article was edited since it was originally posted or not, but in fairness to the author, it does say “Check out the K-Pop category below:”.

    In other words, it is possible that they just meant “here are the top 5 k-pop artists on the k-pop ringtone chart” rather than “k-pop artists dominate the Japanese ringtone chart”.

    Either way, it is a poorly worded article.

  7. I never liked those authors. For such a “respected” site, it has a lot of grammatical mistakes.

  8. They’re trying to build up the Hallyu wave duh~
    I remember that one article about how Shinee 50k sales beat Kisumai and AKB on Oricon…bitch please. it was the 2nd week and AKB already sold over 1 million on the first day for Flying Get and Kisumai already sold 200k.

    I’m not shock they’re building the Hallyu hype..i’m just surprise people actually buy into this shit of Kpop dominating when most can’t even sell compare to the 48 and JE beside 2 kpoup groups…really? :

  9. OUR STAHZ AH DUH SOOPUH DOOPUH FAEMUHS!!!!

    -_-

    Is it bad that I have little fantasies that include me flying over to Korea, attending live performances of kpop’s biggest acts, and ask people in the crowd who the funny looking people are on stage (it would be even better if I asked who the Japanese people were…..)? They need to freaking realize that they sound so delusional and narcissistic when trying to come off as a big deal. People there need reality checks. This blog could really help with that, too bad there are more sites like Allkpop that try to convince crazy Kpop fans that Kpop isn’t a total fail.

  10. The more they hype up kpop the more stupid the fans become.

    But like they say “Ignorance is bliss”

  11. A ringtone chart… That’s supposed to be special?

    Making such a big fuss over nothing.

Scroll To Top