Both Seungkwan of SEVENTEEN and Soobin of TXT are known for being girl group stans, and so it was a special treat to see them debating the topic like fans would on Boo Seungkwan’s Bibbidi Bobbidi Boo on his YouTube.
I was actually surprised by how quickly things got “heated”, as after some friendly discussion, things kicked off right away when K-pop groups were brought up, specifically when it got directed to KARA‘s hit “Jumping” came up, as Seungkwan choose the track as his favorite song while Soobin doesn’t even think it’s among KARA’s best.
Seungkwan: Why? I don’t get it!
Soobin: The instrumental is really good, but the melody is, gosh, wasn’t the melody so carelessly composed?
Seungkwan: What are you talking about? Do you even know how those Sweetune folks came up with that topline melody?
Soobin: It’s too repetitive. The bridge part is repetitive, and the verse and chorus, too, all of it. Maybe they should have at least given variations in the lyrics.
Seungkwan: You don’t know its appeal.
I’m with Soobin here. “Jumping” is great, but not even sure it’s in their own Top 5.
이런 논쟁을 4세대 케이팝 댓글창에서도 여럿본것같음 pic.twitter.com/XFb5k3n8ap
— pm. (@plus_moa_) February 5, 2026
As the episode progressed, they also talked about Wonder Girls being Seungkwan’s favorite, and he named SECRET, Nine Muses, and Rainbow as the others he stanned. Dude is basically a Sweetune stan, which makes him incredibly based. Meanwhile, besides KARA, Soobin choose Rainbow, Apink, and miss A.
soobin and his fave ggs after kara!
— jaz 🐰🍀 (@twelve05cm) February 5, 2026
1. rainbow (junior group of kara)
🐰 it's a love that goes down the family tree
2. apink
🐰 actually, girl's day and apink were seriously top tier during our generation. personally, rather than girl's day, i liked apink better
🐰 i kind of… pic.twitter.com/SME7ymo0jO
They also go into great detail explaining specifically what they like, and Seungkwan also dropped a CHI CHI reference out of nowhere. They released like three singles over two years over a decade ago. What a psycho, in the best way.
Of course, their favorite boy groups weren’t neglected, with Seungkwan going for INFINITE, BOYFRIEND, and B.A.P, while Soobin had BTS, B.A.P, and Block B.
——
Honestly the whole thing was just engaging, as I feel like we rarely see popular active idols discussing other popular mostly active idols like they are on Stan Twitter having a debate. This exact kind of discourse is just what goes on constantly with K-pop fandoms, and thus it’s probably as widely relatable as anything. Reminiscing about collab stages from 2012? Two idols after my heart.
Anyway, whole video is subbed and really the series is worth watching.
Asian Junkie Asian pop. Without discretion.
